Ethnicity Vs. Career

22/09/2018
Mr. Michael Molenaar


Ethnicity Vs. Career
By: Isabelle John


“Mother Tongue”, by Amy Tan discusses the issues of not knowing the prestige dialect of English in great depth. The author also mentions that her own teachers would tend to steer her to fields they thought she’d be good at due to her ethnicity, being math or science, instead of English and writing. There is a stigma around ethnicity driving an individual’s career, when in reality it usually doesn’t work out. For example, Indians are steered towards professions in the IT, engineering, and medical fields.


This is not an accurate representation of a culture or ethnicity or the talents of an individual. They should be allowed to pursue any career, with the full support of their school and teachers, instead of the disapproval and pressure to pursue something they are alleged to be good at, but don’t consider enjoyable.


Do what you love, and you won’t work a day in your life. This is a very common phrase passed around, and applies to this situation. If an individual is pressured to pursue a career just because they’re alleged to be good at it or are supposed to do it just because of their ethnicity or race, they will most likely have a very depressing life. Instead individuals should be supported to pursue whatever they please and pursue a career that interests them and stimulates their lives. There is no relationship between ethnicity and career, each individual has something special to offer and should be allowed to explore that.


Being good at the prestige dialect of English shouldn’t result in the esteemed jobs being handed over when there are higher qualified individuals. Being able to communicate effectively is an intellectual gain and being multilingual allows you to do that.


Take for example me, I am an Indian by ethnicity however I do not want to become an IT professional or an engineer or even pursue any careers in the medical field. I want to become a lawyer which is generally not something you’d associate with the “Indian” careers. If I was forced by my teachers to become an engineer I would potentially be miserable for the rest of my life.

Like mentioned before, ethnicity has no correlation to career, and knowing the prestige dialect of English should also not have any correlation to career. An individual should pursue any career, and as long as they are able to communicate effectively in their field. should be encouraged to continue in their field and continuously supported, because language is power, and language is not only English. It can be any language, any dialect, and any idiolect, as long as YOU, as a human being chase your dreams and strive for success.

Comments

  1. Excellent Job! You generally followed the conventions of an opinion column; you use good logos in each of the statements you claim, you give a context for your opinion that is newsworthy, and finally you established a voice in your writing that follows the conventions of an opinion column. I do agree with your statement about the general society judging and assuming your occupation simply based on your race. as being an Arab everybody normally expects me to be an engineer. The main improvement that I would like to point out is backing up your statements with hard facts, as that is one of the main conventions that is presented in an opinion column. Apart from that this was an excellent piece of work Isabelle.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Your response showed a good understanding of issues surrounding stereotyping. The content you selected effectively supported your ideas and your response was well organized and coherent. You avoided overly academic language, but could have strived for a more unique voice. Moving forward, more attention to the conventions of a text type can improve the overall quality of your work. Making this more newsworthy by not leading off with a reference to the text we studied in class, working in some facts, in addition to grounding this in a real context would have improved the overall authenticity. Well done!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment